Myths & Facts About H.R. 875

A new piece of legislation was introduced to the U.S. Congress several months ago called The Food Safety Modernization Act of 2009, or also known as H.R. 875. In short, this bill would create a new department, The Food Safety Administration, that would be within the existing Department of Health and Human Services. H.R. 875 is being sponsored by Rosa DeLauro, who represents the third district of Connecticut.

This bill was brought about by the soaring number of cases of salmonella, e. coli, and other outbreaks throughout the country due to tainted produce. H.R. 875’s main purpose is to set guidelines and controls to ensure the safety of imported foods to better the health of Americans.

Because of some language in the bill surrounding organic gardening and local farmers markets, there has been some uproar over this newly proposed bill. Many gardeners and farmers have taken this language to mean the end of organic gardening, and the onset of major constrictions on local farmers markets. To hopefully end some of the rumors and misconception pertaining to The Food Safety Modernization Act of 2009, Congresswoman DeLauro has produced a Myth & Fact Sheet pertaining to H.R. 875:

This Fact & Myth Sheet was obtained from Congresswoman DeLauro’s website,

  • MYTH: H.R. 875 “makes it illegal to grow your own garden” and would result in the “criminalization of the backyard gardener.”
    FACT: There is no language in the bill that would regulate, penalize, or shut down backyard gardens. The focus of the bill is to ensure the safety of food in interstate commerce.
  • MYTH: H.R. 875 would mean a “goodbye to farmers markets” because it would regulate and penalize “each farmer who wishes to sell locally.”
    FACT: There is no language in the bill that would result in farmers markets being regulated, penalized by any fines, or shut down. Farmers markets would be able to continue to flourish under the bill. In fact, the bill would insist that imported foods meet strict safety standards to ensure that unsafe imported foods are not competing with locally-grown foods.
  • MYTH: H.R. 875 would result in the “death of organic farming” or “mandate the use of chemicals or certain types of seeds on organic farms.”
    FACT: There is no language in the bill that would stop or interfere with organic farming. The National Organic Program (NOP) is under the jurisdiction of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). The Food Safety Modernization Act only addresses food safety issues under the jurisdiction of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
  • MYTH: H.R. 875 was written by Monsanto and other large agribusiness companies because Stan Greenberg, Rep. DeLauro’s husband, is a consultant for Monsanto.
    FACT: Monsanto and other large agribusiness companies did not write or express support for H.R. 875. Mr. Greenberg had no involvement in drafting the bill. Greenberg, Quinlan Rosner does no lobbying on any issue and its work is wholly independent. Mr. Greenberg never worked for Monsanto, and has not conducted surveys for Monsanto in the past decade. The bill is supported by several Members of Congress who have strong progressive records on issues involving farmers markets, organic farming, and locally-grown foods. Also, H.R. 875 is the only food safety legislation that has been supported by all of the major consumer food safety groups.

    – Center for Foodborne Illness Research & Prevention
    – Center for Science in the Public Interest
    – Consumer Federation of America
    – Consumers Union
    – Food & Water Watch
    – The Pew Charitable Trusts
    – Safe Tables Our Priority
    – Trust for America’s Health

  • MYTH: H.R. 875 would implement a national animal ID system (NAIS).
    FACT: There is no language in the bill that would implement NAIS, which is under the jurisdiction of the USDA. H.R. 875 addresses issues under the jurisdiction of the FDA.
  • MYTH: H.R. 875 will pass the Congress next week without amendments or debate.
    FACT: Food safety legislation has yet to be considered by any Congressional committee. As legislation moves forward, the House Energy and Commerce Committee will consider H.R. 759 as its base bill. The Senate HELP Committee will consider S. 510 as its base bill.

For more information about this bill, and to read it in its entirety, you can visit these links:

H.R. 875: Food Safety Modernization Act of 2009

3 Comments on Myths & Facts About H.R. 875

  1. HR 875 and HR 2749 puts the US gov’t and Monsantos in control of our food. Why do I have to pay $500 a year for my garden? Well to get our the gov’t out of deubt. Our Habis Corpis is gone under GW and now our 10th amendment will be wiped out. The Bill of Rights and the US Constitution will end up being toilet paper. The Dems and Repubs are flushing our rights down the drain. This is taxation without representation. The CODEX was made by Nazi Socialism, well this is turning into capitalistic Socialism just as Karl Marks predicted. I love my country and my gov’t makes me sick. You can not trust politications an Lawyers.

    (Sorry for any miss-speillings, I am pissed and affraid)

    • Hi Wes,

      What you say may be indeed true. It is the large agricultural companies, such as Monsantos and Conagra, that want this bill to be passed. It will help drive out their biggest competition – the local gardener and farmer. HR875 is supposed to be about establishing safety guidelines when dealing with food/produce because of the rash of viral and bacterial outbreaks in recent years. These outbreaks mostly come from the large agribusinesses like ConAgra, not organic gardeners and farmers markets. Once again our gov’t is barking up the wrong tree.

      Look at how the chemical pesticide/ fertilizer companies reacted when Michelle Obama announced her garden would be organic. They all flipped out and begged her to mention chemical products. She refused.

      All in all, it is all about the mighty dollar with businesses and our gov’t.

  2. All you have to do is read the Bill. Read the definition of “Food production facility” in the
    definitions section of the bill , then read section 206, then tell me what you think.

3 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. uberVU - social comments
  2. Tweets that mention Myths & Facts On H.R. 875 : Veggie Gardener --
  3. Senate bill S510 could mean the end of ecological agriculture - Discussion and Information Forums

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.